How to Beat Cheap: Five Ways to Successfully Compete Against Low-Cost Legal Providers

This article was originally written by Daniel Decker for our client exclusive Spotlight Quarterly publication in the April 2017 Edition. Daniel is the co-founder of Spotlight Branding.

The legal industry is highly competitive and becoming more so every day- you don’t need me to tell you that. There are more lawyers practicing than ever before, and meanwhile the popularity of free or dirt-cheap online services like LegalZoom, along with the emergence of platforms like Avvo Advisor which connect consumers with lawyers willing to work for low flat rates, there’s tremendous pressure to lower prices and conform to the demands of the market.

If you’re hoping to build a profitable, sustainable practice that provides a great living for yourself and your family, this is obviously a cause for concern. But here’s the good news: there’s an opportunity created by these market forces that you can exploit. You just have to do things differently than most of the other solo/small firms out there who are responding to these market forces by cutting rates, offering poor client-service, cutting costs, and generally racing for the bottom.

Prospering in these conditions requires a mindset shift. It requires you to accept the fact that there are many consumers and businesses out there – perhaps even a majority – who will choose the low-cost provider every time. They’ll get it done online if they can. If they have to hire a lawyer, they’ll hire the cheapest lawyer they can possibly find. Don’t chase those clients. You don’t have to. Instead, focus your marketing efforts on a market segment who can and will pay premium rates because they recognize the superior value you are providing.

In every industry, there are hugely profitable businesses that charge premium rates and still win business despite the availability of free alternatives. Here’s my favorite example: think about the most readily-available commodity we all enjoy – breathable air. It keeps us alive, and it’s free! Now Google “oxygen bars.” You’ll likely find several near you – establishments where you can easily pay $60 an hour to breathe pure oxygen, which offers no actual health benefits compared to “normal” air according to medical professionals. But yet, customers are lining up to pay for it, despite being literally surrounded by a free alternative. It’s an extreme example but I hope you can see the point: If an entire industry can thrive by selling air – readily available for free, you know, everywhere around us – at high prices, there’s no reason for you to panic when you hear about low-cost competitors. You just need a strategy to attract the right clientele – people who have the means to pay your rates and who see the value in doing so.

Here are five steps to make this happen:

Target the right market. The first step is shifting your mindset, as discussed above. Accept that many/most people out there are not good clients for you. Don’t target clients who can’t afford to pay you premium rates. If that means shifting your focus and maybe getting into some new practice areas, so be it. It’s much harder to build a profitable business when you have a low-profit margin. Target clients who can afford premium rates and provide sufficient value to justify those rates.

Narrow your focus and become the expert. The key to differentiating yourself from the low-cost options – at the same time making yourself more attractive to the premium clients you’re targeting – is to narrow your focus and build a brand as a leading expert in that area. I strongly recommend focusing on a single practice area or a group of related practice areas. Then, work to build your reputation as the “go-to” guy or gal in your market for that specific area of practice. Publish articles and blog entries. Launch a podcast. Speak at conferences, seminars, industry functions. Look for opportunities to get on the radio, on TV, in the newspaper. Write a book.

Build – and cultivate – your referral network. Referrals are one of the very best ways to fill your pipeline with prospective clients who are willing and able to pay premium rates. When you build a network of referral sources who trust your expertise, believe in your work, and understand the value you provide, they act as the best kind of gatekeeper. They’ll send you good clients who are happy to pay your rates, and they won’t waste your time with clients who aren’t a good fit. A major focus of your marketing should be maintaining relationships with your referral network and continually reminding them of what you do, why they can trust you, and what makes a good referral.

Demonstrate the “hidden cost” of low-cost alternatives. It’s important to show prospective clients that there are significant hidden costs that come along with low-cost alternatives. Less desirable outcomes, poor service, etc. For example, LegalZoom will create a Will for $69, so it’s your job to communicate the hidden cost of that decision. “Is it really worth saving $1200 now when you’re literally putting your family’s entire future at risk in the process?” Choosing the cheap provider is generally not the best decision and will often be far more costly in the long run. Make that clear to prospective clients.

Eliminate the competition. Not by taking action against them, but by transforming yourself. If there’s too much competition in your market segment, create a new segment for yourself. If you can accomplish this, you’re selling in a vacuum – there’s nobody your potential clients can price-shop you against. This requires innovation and an open mind. How can you enhance, combine, or structure your services to create something that nobody else offers? If you haven’t thought about this before, it’s worth blocking off a few hours to consider. What resources do you have… what relationships can you leverage… what unique value can you create… how can you mix, match, and restructure your current offerings? What can you do to place yourself in a “category of one” and make the competition irrelevant because nobody else can offer what you offer?

If you’d like to learn more about how we help solo & small law firms grow their practice, schedule your FREE consultation with us HERE.

If you found this post helpful, please share it!Share on Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter
Share on LinkedIn
Share on Google+
Email this to someone
The following two tabs change content below.

Spotlight Branding

Spotlight Branding is an internet marketing and branding firm for lawyers. Our goal is to help our clients create an online presence that positions them as a credible expert in their field, keeps them connected with their network in order to stay top of mind and increase referrals, and to become more visible online so prospects can find them!

Latest posts by Spotlight Branding (see all)

View Our Work with Client Examples

View Our Work with Client Examples

Click below to see some of the work we have done for other lawyers.



See what other attorneys say about their experience with Spotlight Branding:

“As the owner of a growing law firm, it is impossible to spend the amount of time necessary to keep up my firm…
Amy HoffmanAPH Law, PLLCPuyallup, WA
“Spotlight Branding designed our web site and now provides our ongoing  web marketing. The Spotlight Brandi…
Ray GarciaLaw Offices of Ray Garcia, P.A.Miami, FL
“Spotlight Branding took my idea and made it into a wonderful brand. The development process was quick and eas…
Jaime TophamTopham Family LawGrantsville, UT
“My firm has been using Spotlight Branding for over 2 years and our firm’s gross income has more than doubled …
Vanessa VasquezVasquez de Lara Law GroupMiami, FL
“I have worked with a number of other online marketing firms over the last few years and Spotlight Branding ha…
Lewis LanderholmLanderholm LawPortland, OR

“The number of attorney referrals we receive on a daily basis has doubled since we retained Spotlight Brandi…

Eric ToscanoTenant Law GroupSan Francisco, CA
“I would call myself a website connoisseur. I review lists like, ‘Top Ten Lawyer Websites of the Year.’ I had …
Jane MuirJ. Muir & AssociatesMiami, FL
“I hired Spotlight Branding to recreate my website, which I had built myself. Spotlight Branding actively soug…
Bob Boeshaar Law Offices of Robert V. BoeshaarSeattle, WA
“From start to finish, Spotlight Branding has exceeded my expectations.  Their team of professionals jumped r…
Lori HulbertHulbert & Associates, LLCSterling, CO
“When I started with Spotlight Branding, I was a year into having my own practice.  After utilizing Spotlight’…
Brett TremblyThe Trembly Law FirmMiami, FL
“I have recently worked with Spotlight Branding on creating a revised website for my firm. They were very easy…
George HoughProActive Legal Care Law OfficePalm City, FL
“Since hiring Spotlight Branding, I have seen significant measurable results. My referrals have steadily incre…
Chris ClarkThe Law Office of Chris Clark, PLLCCharlotte, NC
“Our law firm has been using Spotlight Branding for all of our internet marketing for nearly two years. The te…
Brielle MarkWeisberg Kainen Mark, Attorneys at LawMiami, FL
“My exposure has increased exponentially since engaging the services of Spotlight Branding. The traffic I rece…
Christina McKinnonLaw Office of Christina A. McKinnonMiami, FL
“Best company ever! John is awesome and he does a fabulous job. I am very grateful to have him and his team wo…
Jeffrey HensleyHensley Legal Services, PLLCTulsa, OK
“I have had a great experience with Spotlight Branding. I work with John and his team and they always follow u…
Thomas InkelaarInkelaar LawOmaha, NE
“My law firm has been using Spotlight and John Hinson for about 6 months. We are very happy with their level a…
William O'LearyLegacy Planning Law GroupJacksonville, FL
“Excellent service and always on time! I can directly attribute a substantial percentage of our business growt…
Ethan DunnMaxwell Dunn PLCSouthfield, MI
“There is so much that Spotlight Branding has done for me over the last year to make my business that much bet…
Melissa PearceLaw Office of Melissa M. PearceMilford, MI
“Spotlight Branding has been terrific. They know their stuff and do great work. We have been with Spotlight fo…
Gregory McCollumGreg McCollum Complete Legal Defense TeamMyrtle Beach, SC
“Top notch company to keep you in front of your clients. Spotlight Branding has been with us from day one and…
John TottenJohn M. Totten, P.C. Attorney at LawAthens, AL
“Spotlight Branding helped me create a blog that was awarded the 4th best in the country for my practice area.
Barry WaxLaw Offices of Barry M. WaxMiami, FL
“Excellent Service!! Spotlight Branding has been vital in helping us grow. They always respond quickly to ques…
Jose BenitezThe Trembly Law FirmMiami, FL
“I could not be more pleased in working with Spotlight Branding! They really caught my vision for my website, …
Christina HollwarthHollwarth Law Firm, PLLCLongview, TX
“Can’t say enough about Spotlight Branding and the work they do for me, particularly my account representative…
Neil TyraThe Tyra Law FirmRockville, MD
“Spotlight Branding is very responsive, proactive and easy to work with. Great results. I highly recommend th…
Anis SalehSaleh & AssociatesMiami, FL
“I have been extremely pleased with Spotlight Branding. My website is beautiful and I LOVE it! Big applause fo…
Kayleene WriterLaw Offices of Kayleene H. Writer, PLCIrvine, CA